Monthly Archives: February 2004

Clades

66 ballots received so far.

Another observation. Which isn’t new news; you can deduce this from the statistics from past years (number of ballots, number of votes per category). Most ballots register votes for only one or two novels, and that’s all (aside from survey answers). A minority, say one out of ten, or even fewer, submit votes in all five spaces for sf novel, all five for fantasy novel, all five for novella, etc. More like one out of twenty. Nearer the end I’ll calculate actual statistics.

Another Locus Online special year-in-review piece, by Cynthia Ward, is in edit and will be posted shortly.

Voting Early, and Often

The online ballot for the Locus Poll and Survey is up and running, and already over a dozen ballots have been received. Voting is open for nearly three full months, so there’s no reason to vote right away, especially since readers are encouraged to catch up on books and stories they might have missed–using, of course, Locus’ handy Recommended Reading List, and the reviewer essays that appear in the February issue–before voting.

Whether due to the posting of the ballot, or more likely of the Recommended Reading List, traffic to Locus Online surged on Tuesday, to over twice the typical daily high– over 18,000 unique visitors.

Votes in the poll generally trickle in at a steady rate from February, when the the ballot goes online, through the April or May deadline, with only a slight surge at the end as the deadline approaches. Having tabulated the votes the past 2 or 3 years (by importing the emailed form submissions into a database), I’ve noticed some interesting trends in how people vote, and how the votes accumulate. Without of course being too specific, I may mention some of these in the coming weeks as the ballots come in.

Here’s one general observation to start. Though there are usually one or two close categories every year, in most categories in most years the eventual winner is apparent after only 40 or 50 ballots have been received. (The grand total being 5 or 600 or more.) Seeing this happen makes me much less skeptical about political polls, which are often criticized for using such small samples. (It’s not the sample size, it’s the selection.) That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t bother to vote unless you can vote early, of course. You won’t know which categories are close or not, and your vote might well determine a close category, even at the very end.

Update 7.30 p.m. PST: about 40 ballots received, so far.

Technical Difficulties, Please Stand By

The online ballot for the Locus Poll and Survey is ready and was posted briefly last night before I realized that none of the test submissions I sent were appearing in my inbox. So I removed the homepage link and went investigating at my hosting service (that’s CI Host), and quickly found this notice:


We regret to inform our Customers that the dp_tellafriend, cgiemail, insecure formmail, totmail, and alienform scripts have been disabled on all servers due to continual abuse.

Naturally, they had not notified their Customers of this, beyond posting the notice on their own website.

The key to part of the solution is ‘insecure’. So the link to the poll form has to go through the secure server (i.e., https:// [etc]). Did that, submitted more tests, still didn’t work. Further investigation uncovered revisions to the formmail cgi script, requiring the recipient email address in the form to explicitly match the email, or at least the format of the email, specified in the cgi script. All of these changes are spam-preventative measures, supposedly. Anyway, I made further changes, and am awaiting confirmation from Locus HQ that the latest test submissions got to where they’re supposed to go. When everything looks OK, the ballot form will be back online.

I’m 90% over the flu, though it apparently has a long trailing edge.