Mehdi Hasan on Arguing

Two interviews with and a book by Mehdi Hasan, about how to argue, and win arguments, using emotional connections over facts and figures, critical thinking skills, with the difficulty in conducting “good-faith” arguments with the right. How some victims of right-wing media are lost. With references to the Gish Gallop, and John Stuart Mills.

Salon, Dean Obeidallah, 28 Feb 2023: MSNBC’s Mehdi Hasan: You need “rhetorical judo” to challenge the far right, subtitled “Here’s what Hasan says too many left-liberal arguments fail to grasp: ‘We are emotional creatures, not logical'”

Continue reading →

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Culture | Comments Off on Mehdi Hasan on Arguing

Leftover February Links, 2

Science, Culture, Politics

  • A 3-D map of near space, and errors in film and TV science fiction, and a novel; 11 recent scientific breakthroughs; a Lunar time zone.
  • When reading went silent.
  • Ron DeSantis’ freedom crackdown, and a question about systematic racism; Putin’s parallel universe; spreading propaganda for fun and profit; and about the crazies.

Science

Continue reading →

Posted in Culture, Politics, Science | Comments Off on Leftover February Links, 2

Leftover February Links, 1

Politics, Science, Culture, Religion

GOP, NYT and Biden; Evolution, Aliens and Balloons; Movie Credits, Awards; He Gets Us, Indoctrination Camps, Education

Continue reading →

Posted in Culture, Politics, Religion, Science | Comments Off on Leftover February Links, 1

There are “Theories” and then there are “Theories”

I have an idea I haven’t heard or read anyone express before: that some of the confusion about science on the one hand, and the legitimacy of crazy, sometimes deliberately fabricated, nonsensical ideas about what’s going on in the world on the other hand, is due to the use of the word “theory” to describe both.

Continue reading →

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Psychology, Science | Comments Off on There are “Theories” and then there are “Theories”

Zodiacal Light, and The Well

Two more items for today, which I decided not to squeeze into the previous post.

Continue reading →

Posted in Astronomy, Personal history | Comments Off on Zodiacal Light, and The Well

Items from Big Think about Science and Philosophy

How fast is the Earth moving, and in what direction? How the ancient Greek philosophers were mostly wrong but blazed conceptual trails. And thought experiments that challenge conventional thinking.

Continue reading →

Posted in Philosophy, Science | Comments Off on Items from Big Think about Science and Philosophy

More about the Crazy Fringes

The crazy fringes being Fox News, Fox & Friends, Arizona Republicans, and conservatives who believe in witches and demons. With a palette cleansing quote from Carl Sagan.

Continue reading →

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Lunacy | Comments Off on More about the Crazy Fringes

I do not think this study means what this writer thinks it means

(Added Sunday: another take on the same study from a writer at Vox.)

NYT, Bret Stephens, 21 Feb 2023: The Mask Mandates Did Nothing. Will Any Lessons Be Learned?

A conservative columnist for the NY Times claims a meta-study on the efficacy of masks for reducing the spread of respiratory illness has concluded that they didn’t work.

Continue reading →

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Science | Comments Off on I do not think this study means what this writer thinks it means

Two Philosophical Bits

Are you the same person you were last week? How long should you shop?

Continue reading →

Posted in Philosophy, science fiction | Comments Off on Two Philosophical Bits

Arguing to Win, Not to Be Right

Two books about how to argue; more on the “national divorce”; and items about the right-wing battle for the next century, train deregulation, a new target list of enemies, and buying your way onto bestseller lists.

Here’s a review in today’s NYT of two books about arguing.

NYT, Jennifer Szalai, 22 Feb 2023: Fight or Make Nice? Two Books Consider How to Listen and Be Heard., subtitled “‘Win Every Argument,’ by Mehdi Hasan, and ‘Say the Right Thing,’ by Kenji Yoshino and David Glasgow, offer different approaches to talking to others.

Continue reading →

Posted in Politics, Psychology | Comments Off on Arguing to Win, Not to Be Right