César Hidalgo, WHY INFORMATION GROWS

Subtitled “The Evolution of Order, from Atoms to Economies”
(Basic Books, 2015, xxi + 232 pp, including 51pp of acknowledgements, notes, and index)

A few weeks ago I sat down to read the new Yuval Noah Harari book, NEXUS, and just a few pages in noticed a footnote crediting much of his understanding of the concept of “information” to César Hildago’s WHY INFORMATION GROWS. And I realized, I have that book! It’s that green one! So I got it off the shelf and browsed a bit. His thesis based on that browsing seemed very similar, at least analogous if not identical, to a key idea in the Brian Greene book I read recently, UNTIL THE END OF TIME (review here) — the idea that order can build up, despite the 2nd law of thermodynamics, but only *temporarily*, even if temporary means billions of years, because of the course of the life of the *entire* universe, that order (or information) will dissolve back into entropy. (Greene calls this “the entropic two-step”.) How interesting! That meant the little green Hidalgo book has ties to two other big books. So I set Harari aside, to get Hidalgo’s ideas from the source. And here we are. How does this idea relate to “information”? How exactly does he define “information”? That’s what Harari deals with too.

(More broadly, the idea of that evolution can happen despite the 2nd law of thermodynamics, an idea disputed by naive, ill-educated people who desperately want evolution to be untrue so that can think their Bible is true, relates to a broad range of topics. And another 2015 book I haven’t read, Matt Ridley’s THE EVOLUTION OF EVERYTHING.)

So: the universe is made of energy, matter, and information, and it’s the last that makes it interesting. It hides in pockets at the universe succumbs to entropy. Nevertheless, information grows. Without summarizing the entire book, here are some key points:

Continue reading

Posted in Book Notes, Cosmology, Economics, Evolution | Comments Off on César Hidalgo, WHY INFORMATION GROWS

How Much Is There Left to Say?

  • David French: There will always be a Trump;
  • David Frum: No one has an alibi;
  • Facts, if anyone cares, about the economy under Biden and Trump (On 17 points: Biden advantage 11, Trump advantage 5, and 1 unclear);
  • How Musk’s mother claims she can vote multiple times; How a Project 2025 leader suggests Christians will be forbidden to worship; How maps show that Trump and his fans actually despise most Americans; Zach Beauchamp compares Trump to Orbán; Gingrich is infuriated over the idea that wives might vote differently than their husbands; Vance suggests testosterone aligns with conservative politics; and how Trump has lured evangelicals to follow Satan.
– – –

NY Times, David French, 3 Nov 2024: There Will Always Be a Trump. That’s Only Part of the Problem.

This echoes a key theme of my blog; as I said in my summary of the Prothero book yesterday, “there will always be gays and bigots.” Base human nature will never go away. But it’s despite that that humanity has made progress.

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, conservatives, Lunacy, Politics, Religion | Comments Off on How Much Is There Left to Say?

Ramping Up

It’s happening right before our eyes.

  • How Trump’s 2020 Playbook is being put into action;
  • Trump simulates oral sex in public;
  • Jonathan M. Katz on what Trump’s team will do following the election;
  • Robert Reich reminds us of 101 terrible things Trump has done;
– – –

NY Times, Jim Rutenberg and Alan Feuer, 2 Nov 2024: Trump, Preparing to Challenge the Results, Puts His 2020 Playbook Into Action, subtitled “Step by step, Donald J. Trump and his allies are following the strategies that caused chaos four years ago. Election officials say they are ready this time.” [gift link]

Former President Donald J. Trump and his allies are rolling out a late-stage campaign strategy that borrows heavily from the subversive playbook he used to challenge his loss four years ago.

Continue reading

Posted in conservatives, Human Nature, Politics | Comments Off on Ramping Up

Prothero: WHY LIBERALS WIN THE CULTURE WARS…

(EVEN WHEN THEY LOSE ELECTIONS), subtitled “The Battles That Define America from Jefferson’s Heresies to Gay Marriage”

(HarperOne, Oct 2016, 326pp, including 62p acknowledgements, notes, and index.)

I’ve mentioned this book a few times, the first time even before it was published (in Dec 2014), and I finally sat down to read it closely a few weeks ago. Well, a portion of it closely. The book consists of a framing argument, and five chapters of examples covering over 200 pages. I read the framing argument, and the fifth example, totaling about 100 pages. Much of the framing argument was already there from the video I linked in 2014 (though the link has changed to this.)

The gist of the book, in my own terms, begins with the recognition that change is ongoing and inescapable. (At least since the Enlightenment, the Industrial Revolution, and the expansion of humanity around the globe that has brought previously isolated groups and cultures into contact with one another and so forced them to learn how to get along. This dovetails with my comments two days ago under the “what does this say about us?” article.)

Continue reading

Posted in Book Notes, conservatives, Culture, Human Progress | Comments Off on Prothero: WHY LIBERALS WIN THE CULTURE WARS…

Another Trumpy Day

  • Trump imagines Liz Cheney before a firing squad;
  • A history of Trump’s violent remarks;
  • And his “enemies list”;
  • Trumpists’ playbook for trying to overturn the election — check back next week;
  • How Trump appeals to America’s xenophobic history;
  • When leopards tell you they will eat your face, believe them;
  • Another asking of the question, Who are we, America?;
  • Trump doesn’t have the attention span for a coup;
  • And consideration of what will actually happen if Trump wins, with my own predictions.
– – –

The Atlantic, David A. Graham, 1 Nov 2024: Trump Suggests Training Guns on Liz Cheney’s Face, subtitled “Let’s put her with a rifle standing there with nine barrels shooting at her, okay?”

\

It’s nothing really new.

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Politics | Comments Off on Another Trumpy Day

And Now We’re Talking about Garbage

How the mighty have fallen.

  • What does Trump being a narcissistic sociopath say about us? I have some ideas;
  • How another confrontation by a child to her Trump-voting father does not go well;
  • More about Trump’s, and Biden’s, garbage comments;
  • How Trump fans are already planning to contest the election;
  • And how Trump promises to protect women “whether they like it or not.”

Despite the “again” MAGA clearly believes the United States is the greatestest country in the whole world ever, because of Jesus and whatnot, despite all the Democrats, and the press, and the elites on coasts, and Puerto Rico. And despite the Constitution, which they flout at every turn. Cognitive dissonance indeed.

LGBTQNation, Molly Sprayregen, 31 Oct 2024: Donald Trump is a narcissistic sociopath. So what does that say about us?

Continue reading

Posted in Human Nature, Politics | Comments Off on And Now We’re Talking about Garbage

And So Here We Are

  • Trump’s closing argument is vulgarity;
  • How Trump is unable to produce evidence of voter fraud; Similarly, how a far-right social media personality is unable to substantiate his calumny against James Carville;
  • Shorter items: How Trump pardons only those loyal to him; how a Christian pastor cherry-picks the Bible; how presidents do not actually control much of the economy; how those who support Trump’s mass deportation aren’t thinking things through; how immigration actually affects the US economy; and how a Christian pastor still believe in demons.
– – –

Washington Post, Editorial Board, 29 Oct 2024: Opinion | Donald Trump’s closing argument: Vulgarity, subtitled “Trump has made politics coarser, and somehow he’s managed to become even cruder in recent days.”

Continue reading

Posted in Culture, Politics, Religion | Comments Off on And So Here We Are

Appropriate Terminology

Several good items published today.

  • We’re stuck in the Trump Loop because we can’t accept that sociopaths exist;
  • Steven Pinker with data that says the country is *not* ‘dying’;
  • Another piece about psychological “blind spots” and how to counter them;
  • How Trump is better described, not as a fascist, but as a “demagogue”;
  • How Trump lacks not only empathy, but sorrow;
  • And: I predict the election will be so close that MAGA and Trump will claim Trump’s victory, and bad things will happen, worse than January 6th. I hope I’m wrong.
– – –

Beginning with yet another item about why so many people like Trump.

Slate, Steven Reisner, 29 Oct 2024: The Deep Psychological Reason We’re Stuck in This Feedback Loop With Donald Trump, subtitled “It’s been almost a decade, and yet it continues.”

To cut to the chase, Reisner’s answer is that people don’t realize that sociopaths actually exist, with an example of women who date men who turn out to be sociopaths.

Continue reading

Posted in Human Nature, Politics, progress | Comments Off on Appropriate Terminology

The Latest Display by the Despicables

You can’t escape it. He keeps topping himself. Items today are all about Trump’s Madison Square Garden rally yesterday. With some concluding thoughts about human nature and that famous William Gibson quote.

CNN, 28 Oct 2024: Trump unveils the most extreme closing argument in modern presidential history, subtitled “His rhetoric ranks among the most flagrant demagoguery by a major figure of any Western nation since World War II”

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, conservatives, Human Nature, Lunacy, Politics | Comments Off on The Latest Display by the Despicables

Violence as a Public Health Issue, and Media Bias

Two New Yorker pieces today.

I mentioned an article a couple weeks ago about whether violence is a disease (or actually, whether MAGA is a disease like violence is taken to be). Here’s another perspective.

The New Yorker, Michael Luo, 17 Oct 2024: Should Political Violence Be Addressed Like a Threat to Public Health?, subtitled “Treating political violence as a contagion could help safeguard the future of American democracy.”

The essay begins by recalling the filth in mid-19th century New York City streets, and the rash of deaths in car crashes in the 1950s. Both were treated as matters of public health and largely fixed.

Continue reading

Posted in Politics, Social Progress | Comments Off on Violence as a Public Health Issue, and Media Bias