Stories and Reality

  • Are more Americans seeing the truth behind the GOP lies?;
  • Evidence that disputes Trump’s promises, in 11 charts;
  • Robert Reich tells Scott Bessent who’s wrong and who’s right;
  • Paul Krugman wonders why Trump likes North Korea, the worst government on Earth;
  • Rep. Jared Huffman’s frank discussion of Christian Nationalism;
  • Haitink conducts Bruckner 4.
– – –

Some people (whom we call conservatives) won’t ‘believe’ any kind of evidence that disputes their stories.

The New Republic, yesterday: At Long Last, Americans Are Starting to See the Truth About the GOP, subtitled “A businessman can set this country right. Republicans are better for the economy. Republicans love the military. Lie, lie, and lie. ”

But the last three Republican presidents—Bush, Bush, and Trump—have been disasters. The first Bush oversaw a double-dip recession and a massive savings and loan scandal that looted the treasury. The second Bush started a costly and tragic war based on lies and nearly brought the global economy to its knees. Trump, you know about—corruption, fascism, and staggering incompetence.

Continue reading

Posted in conservatives, Music, Politics, Religion | Comments Off on Stories and Reality

How the American Experiment May Not Be Working

  • Adam Lee suggests abolishing the US Senate (as others have before him)

America has always considered itself an experiment, on the world stage, and in fact it has developed into the most powerful nation on Earth. But has the experiment been entirely successful? Is America perfect? The test of any experiment and its conclusions is whether they can stand up to later discoveries and experiments and their conclusions. Things change.

OnlySky, Adam Lee, today: For the good of democracy, abolish the Senate, subtitled “It’s an oligarchic institution designed to thwart the popular will.”

Continue reading

Posted in History, Politics | Comments Off on How the American Experiment May Not Be Working

Caro Claire Burke, YESTERYEAR

(Knopf, April 2026, 391pp)

I read the bestselling novel YESTERYEAR, by Caro Claire Burke, three weekends ago, on a trip to LA to spend time with family on the occasion of a 1st birthday and a new house, and it turned out to be a perfect book for such a trip. In such family gatherings things are going on all around me that don’t need my attention (especially on Open House day when 50 people were wandering around the house and property), and this book was an easy read as I sat on the sofa, or retired to our guest room.

It’s difficult to discuss this book without spoiling it in one direction or another. I added it to my Weekly Bestsellers page, on Locus Online, beginning April 20th, because the various descriptions of the book implied it involved time travel — a contemporary woman goes back to 1855.

Spoiler: Continue reading

Posted in Book Notes, Culture | Comments Off on Caro Claire Burke, YESTERYEAR

Fantasy Lands

  • Andrew O’Hehir on how few people understand the differences between socialism, capitalism, and all those other isms, as even MAGA embraces socialist ideas;
  • Mark Joseph Stern on the origin of originalist ideas about the US Constitution;
  • Jamelle Boudie on how Trump is living in a fantasy land;
  • Two items about Trump’s underwhelming “Patriot Games.”
– – –

Some of us are more closely aligned with reality than others.

Another in a series about how few people know what these various terms actually mean.

Salon, Andrew O’Hehir, today: Even MAGA loves socialism now, subtitled “Everyone’s done with capitalism — except mainstream Democrats, late to the party as usual”

As you may have noticed, many members of the American media and political classes are currently rending their garments in terror and despair at the perceived threat of “socialism.” It’s not at all clear what that word means in 2026, in this context or any other.

Continue reading

Posted in conservatives, Culture, Politics | Comments Off on Fantasy Lands

David Brin’s Phases of the American Civil War

Still under the weather, for a week now. I’m behind updating sfadb. I spent some time this afternoon refining yesterday’s post. For now, not entirely irrelevant:

Brin has long portrayed American history as the same kind of transition between modes of human nature. He describes several “phases” of the ongoing American Civil War.

David Brin, 19 Sep 2014: Phases of the American Civil War

My point being that this conflict between the varieties of human nature has been playing out for centuries. At least.

Posted in conservatives, Human Nature | Comments Off on David Brin’s Phases of the American Civil War

The Expansion of Human Morality, the Relativity of Good and Evil

  • Further thoughts on the evolutionary forces behind the expansion of human morality;
  • Thought while reading Stephen King’s THE STAND;
  • And further thoughts about human morality, and how conservative and progressive stances have been appropriate at different times;
  • Heather Digby Parton on the roots of science denial: fundamentalist faith and Big Business;
  • And now Trump wants to redesign aircraft carriers, because he knows best.
– – –

Following up on yesterday’s post. (Updated 15aug26)

The idea is that human morality has changed, and we can chart those changes chronologically, and see how it has evolved from a single tribal morality into the spectrum we see today. Sketch:

Humans have existed in their present form for two or three hundred thousand years. As social, tribal creatures, mostly on the African Savannah. That ‘morality’ was hierarchical, primed for reproduction against constant threats of starvation and disease, hostile toward other tribes for resources, bound by common stories that combined with intuitive perceptions of the natural world’s agency to become religions, and so on.

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, History, Human Nature, Human Progress, Psychology | Comments Off on The Expansion of Human Morality, the Relativity of Good and Evil

The Deep History Key to the American Political Divide

  • Kurt Andersen on America’s soft breakup;
  • How the divide goes back ultimately to the Agricultural Revolution.
– – –

First up, a NYT Op-ed

NY Times, Kurt Andersen, 9 Aug 2026: Has America Already Undergone a Soft Breakup?

Continue reading

Posted in Culture, Human Nature, Politics | Comments Off on The Deep History Key to the American Political Divide

MAGA Art Slop; Ignoring the Data

  • MAGA taste in art, and a new exhibit in Washington DC;
  • More Republican destruction: the US Census, and monitoring the Arctic;
  • Maybe they don’t believe they’re lying, they just don’t know the difference between lies and truth;
  • Robert Reich on why MAGA wants children to get sick and die of measles;
  • Aliens stole a Christian televangelist’s eggs and made a hybrid baby;
  • Pettersson #6
– – –

I don’t know why it should necessarily be that conservatives have lousy tastes in art, but it does seem to be so. On one level it’s understandable that conservatives should like ‘representational’ art, e.g. painting of actual things, or music that is lyrical, and reject anything else, such as any kind of abstraction. There’s that cognitive limitation thing again.

And we could discuss Trump, who likes nothing so much as gilt on everything. And lowbrow music for his Kennedy Center and rallies. And wrestling as 4th of July entertainment. Perhaps he has paintings of tigers on black velvet somewhere; surely his MAGA fans do. But let’s look at this:

Slate, Christina Cauterucci, today: I Went to the Trump Admin’s “Patriotic” Art Exhibit. Dear God., subtitled “It was like a HomeGoods display around the Fourth of July.”

Continue reading

Posted in Art, conservatives, Music | Comments Off on MAGA Art Slop; Ignoring the Data

Yuval Noah Harari: UNSTOPPABLE US, Vol. 3

Subtitled: “How Enemies Become Friends”
(Bright Matter Books, February 2026, xxi + 181pp)

Here is the third of Harari’s world’s-history-for-children books, taking a 30,000-foot view of the big changes over the millennia of human history. Each book has four chapters. I’ll recall the first two volumes…

Volume 1: How Humans Took Over the World

  • Humans are animals; there were once different kinds of humans, but only our branch, Sapiens, is still alive;
  • The superpower of Sapiens is the ability to cooperate in large numbers, with the ability to tell imaginary stories and to invent stories about corporations, money, and religion, which work so long as everyone agrees to them;
  • Early humans lived in tribes that grew and split into smaller tribes, were experts about their environment, believed in ghosts and spirits;
  • Over the past 50,000 years humans spread across the globe and killed off all the big animals, especially in Australia and the Americas, without realizing what they were doing.

Volume 2: Why the World Isn’t Fair

  • The agricultural revolution led hunter-gatherers to settle into villages and tend animals; problems of pests and droughts gave opportunities to chiefs and priests and sacrifices to appease the gods;
  • As villages grew, diseases spread, people acquired more possessions, villages fought; farmers and gatherers learned to think differently;
  • Larger communities led to problems, requiring leaders to make decisions, tax collectors, punishments for rule-breakers, and slavery; then writing, numbers, documents, and bureaucracy to keep track of all the documents.
  • You get people to follow the rules by inventing stories about the gods who made the rules; stories weren’t about truth, but were necessary for society to function; and stories can change: part of growing up is learning which stories to keep, and which to change.

Here’s a summary of this third book on four points. (Though this book is a bit lop-sided, the early part consisting of stories about fictional characters discovering the world, the latter part being more substantive.)

Volume 3: How Enemies Become Friends

  • Recalling the stories of Gilgamesh, Jason, Zeus, Jonah, Romulus and Remus; people in different cities worry about monsters, and strange ways in other cities;
  • The secret that brought people together was the market. And that became possible with the invention of money. The most successful story ever told. Though it can be dangerous if people love it too much.
  • History is full of wars, and empires. Empires are unfair, except when it’s your own. And conquered peoples forget their past; societies gradually become mixed. Author tells the story of the Romans, its playwrights, its emperors; its gods and the gods of others gave way to the Jewish god, called here Sky Father, who sent Jesus to tell stories of heaven and Hell. There were so many stories about Jesus a council met to decide which were true, and called that collection “the Bible.” Gradually stories about the old gods were forgotten. Still, people have multiple ancestors. History is complicated; we don’t belong to just one country, and we’re all descended from good guys and bad guys.
  • Is there one true story? Everyone believes in their own. But they can’t all be right. What about those who don’t believe in the Sky Father? Christians gradually destroyed the temples of other gods, insisting those gods were just stories. Their Inquisition killed nonbelievers. Yet different versions of Sky Father said different things about wine and other things. Questions about Sky Father led to the idea of a second god: good and evil, God and the Devil. Questions remain: why do we suffer? A man in India, who came to be known as Buddha, decided instead of arguing about gods, we should look for ways to stop suffering. Sometimes we make ourselves miserable. So put these things out of your mind, said Buddha. Don’t worry about the gods; do your best to help others instead of harming them. Yet people still argue about how to live. Over thousands of years people came up with lots of different rules and stories. The biggest discovery in history helped people decide which stories to believe. That discovery was science.
    (The subject of the next book.)

Continue reading

Posted in Book Notes, Culture, History | Comments Off on Yuval Noah Harari: UNSTOPPABLE US, Vol. 3

The Mathematics of Beauty

  • How mathematics is behind the things we perceive as beautiful, via Marcus du Sautoy;
  • What is Trump trying to accomplish by reducing the number of diseases medicine can prevent children from getting?;
  • Several items show confusion on the right between concepts of communism and socialism;
  • Pettersson #8.
– – –

The deep picture. Humans invoke God for things they find beautiful, without understand why they find certain things beautiful, and other things not. (Whereas God must surely be responsible for everything, including the ugly and disgusting.)

The answer, rather, is that humans have evolved to be pattern-seeking creatures, and see complex mathematical patterns as beauty. And why are we drawn to the beautiful? Perhaps because the order or beauty we perceive in mathematical structures are signs of structure, and health.

Big Think, Jonny Thomson, yesterday: The hidden mathematics behind why you find things beautiful, subtitled “The artistic and the mathematical mind are not so far apart.”

Continue reading

Posted in Art, Music, Philosophy, Politics | Comments Off on The Mathematics of Beauty