AI and Human Nature

Posted on Saturday 19 September 2026 by Mark R. Kelly
  • Considering whether doomers and skeptics about AI are both a little bit right (I remain agnostic);
  • What ‘misalignment’ means;
  • Istvan Csicsery-Ronay on what to expect if AI is built on human literature.
– – –

It’s usually not true that the truth lies somewhere in the middle of two competing claims. If mathematics says 2+2=4 and that infamous pastor who said something like ‘If the Bible said 2=2=5, I would believe it’ says differently, the truth is not that 2+2=4 1/2. Some things are just wrong, e.g. most religious claims that challenge scientific conclusions about the objective reality of the world. Philosophy, and politics, moves forward as they are driven by such unresolved claims. So here’s an issue I haven’t staked a claim yet to either side.

The Atlantic, Charlie Warzel, today: Treat AI Like a Normal Crisis, subtitled “What if the doomers and skeptics are both a little bit right?” [gift link]

Continue reading →

Posted in Human Nature, Narrative | Leave a comment

Alan Lightman: THE MIRACULOUS FROM THE MATERIAL

Posted on Saturday 19 September 2026 by Mark R. Kelly

Subtitled: “Understanding the Wonders of Nature”
(Pantheon, November 2024, ix + 193pp, including 8pp acknowledgements and notes.)

This is a valuable book even though Lightman irks me, as he has in some of his other books, by casually using words like “miraculous” and “spiritual” in ways to indicate his subjective feelings of awe but which are quite different from the common definitions of these words by ordinary people, e.g. that miracles involve God’s intervention, or that spiritual indicates something supernatural. Lightman (who has a PhD from CalTech in physics) is too honest a scientist to literally invoke supernatural causes, and by using those words he’s doing a bait and switch, in a sense, to draw readers in to explore what he explains are entirely naturalistic aspects of the world.

Continue reading →

Posted in Book Notes, Science | Leave a comment

Possibilities of Apocalypse

Posted on Friday 18 September 2026 by Mark R. Kelly
  • An essay about how the dangers of technology, like AI, have been avoided before (e.g. with nuclear technology), through various kinds of government regulations (not to mention international cooperation);
  • And yet there are more incidents of bad AI behavior;
  • Now RFK Jr. wants to investigate chemtrails;
  • Trump is steadily eliminating freedom of the press;
  • Beethoven: String Quarter #14.
– – –

I have no commitment to either side of this, at least not yet. But here’s some perspective.

NY Times, opinion by The Editorial Board, today: Humanity Has Avoided Apocalypse Before. Let’s Do It Again.

Their comparison is to nuclear technology, that emerged in the 1940s and 1950s.
Continue reading →

Posted in Human Nature, Music, Technology | Leave a comment

Sam Harris: FREE WILL

Posted on Friday 18 September 2026 by Mark R. Kelly

(Free Press, March 2012, 83pp, including 17pp acknowledgements, notes, and index)

Here’s another short book on a theme of continuing debate. Like most current scientists and philosophers, Harris tries to explain why the free will humans (naively) think they have cannot actually exist, given what we know about how brains work and how causality works. (Coincidentally, there a case in the news about a mother who killed her children, supposedly under the influence of post-partum syndrome, and how the jury could not reach a decision. The core issue is related to that of free will.) Note claims that free will doesn’t exist doesn’t mean the future is predetermined. That’s where quantum matters make a difference.

This may be a quandary best thought of in terms of different ‘realms,’ as I’ve been exploring. Free will may not exist in the naïve way we think it does, but it’s useful to think it does in the realm of ordinary human interactions.

Continue reading →

Posted in Book Notes, Philosophy, Psychology | Leave a comment

Which Core Education?

Posted on Thursday 17 September 2026 by Mark R. Kelly
  • Conservatives want to install a particular kind of core education in universities;
  • Now Trump threatens to tear down the Kennedy Center, if he can’t get his name on it;
  • Brief items about praying for political success; Trump delusionally thinks the world respects him; how Christians fantasize overturning the Constitution; the Republicans’ neo-Nazi problem; free speech except concerning the gays; dismissing AI concerns like they did climate change and Covid;
  • Schubert’s 9th, “The Great”.
– – –

I’m actually guardedly sympathetic to this.

NY Times, 14 Sep 2026: How Conservatives Are Changing College Requirements, subtitled “Politics and other factors are causing universities to reconsider what classes are part of the core required for graduation. In some places, civics and classics are replacing climate change and sociology.”
Continue reading →

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Education, Lunacy, Music, Religion | Comments Off on Which Core Education?

All the Time in the World

Posted on Wednesday 16 September 2026 by Mark R. Kelly
  • What would you do if you had all the free time in the world?
  • An OnlySky essay explores this question in the context of AI;
  • How Harari anticipated this;
  • My own answer to this question, since I’m retired and do effectively have all the free time in the world;
  • Bruckner 9, Jukka-Pekka Saraste.

Much of this is familiar, but increasingly pertinent.

OnlySky, Susan Fourtané, 9 Sep 2026: Post-work society: The future of life after jobs, subtitled “What would you do if you had all the free time in the world?”
Continue reading →

Posted in Human Progress, Music, Personal history | Comments Off on All the Time in the World

Peter Singer: A DARWINIAN LEFT

Posted on Wednesday 16 September 2026 by Mark R. Kelly

Subtitled: Politics, Evolution and Cooperation
(UK 1999; Yale University Press, 2000, 70pp, including 7pp notes and references)

What’s interesting about this book is the background of progressive idealism that is not widely acknowledged, or perhaps has simply been forgotten. That idealism involved Steven Pinker’s notion of the “blank slate,” the idea that the human mind is malleable and can be formed into any shape and thus, in principle, might be perfectible. Thus some Americans in the 1960s thought you shouldn’t automatically buy boys boy toys, or girls girl toys, because that was playing to cliches, when you could choose to guide children’s minds however you wanted to. (Also, I was just reading something about how Mao with his cultural revolution was trying to retrain Chinese minds into some ideal form. That didn’t work out either.)

Continue reading →

Posted in Book Notes, Evolution, Human Nature, Meaning | Comments Off on Peter Singer: A DARWINIAN LEFT

Art, Heroes, Money

Posted on Tuesday 15 September 2026 by Mark R. Kelly
  • Conservatives and abstract art;
  • Trump threatens to close the Kennedy Center if he can’t get his name on it;
  • EPA easing pollution limits;
  • Robert Reich on why Trump loves AI;
  • Heather Cox Richardson on Russia’s financial support for Donald Jr.’s wedding.
– – –

This is not a surprise. Conservatives are unmoved by abstract art. Art should be about their heroes, or themselves.

The Atlantic, Kelsey Ables, yesterday: Why Does Donald Trump Hate This Sculpture?, subtitled “The president wants the Smithsonian to add a colossal George Washington statue—and remove another work of abstract art in D.C.”
Continue reading →

Posted in Art, conservatives, Morality | Comments Off on Art, Heroes, Money

The Conservative Denial of Existential Threats

Posted on Monday 14 September 2026 by Mark R. Kelly
  • Trump thinks concerns about AI are a hoax;
  • Paul Krugman relates AI to climate change: the MAGA plot(s) to destroy humanity.
– – –

Trump thinks concern about AI is a hoax.

CNN, today: Trump dismisses AI alarms as a ‘HOAX’ — worrying White House officials

President Donald Trump spent Monday angrily rejecting calls from AI industry leaders for more government regulation on their cutting-edge models, making clear in a day-long string of social media posts he considers outpacing China and preserving AI-driven economic gains a higher priority than addressing growing public concerns.

Trump asserted a “SICK conspiracy” was afoot to undermine AI and claimed his oversight alone was enough to prevent models from going rogue. He called concerns a “HOAX,” comparing the technology to the “Global Warming Scam” and the investigation of possible ties between his campaign and the Russian government. He also renewed his support for the data centers that power AI, despite their political unpopularity.

Continue reading →

Posted in conservatives, Human Nature | Comments Off on The Conservative Denial of Existential Threats

Hiking is a Modern Invention

Posted on Sunday 13 September 2026 by Mark R. Kelly
  • The idea of hiking was not a thing until relatively recently;
  • How Trump is stifling free speech;
  • Brief items about hurricanes and methane;
  • Nice Bruckner 6 performance by Myung-Whun Chung.
– – –

First, a think piece. About how the things we take for granted today have not always been so.

Washington Post, opinion by Dominic Pino, today: A hike through the woods feels natural. It’s anything but, subtitled “The industrial revolution provided the impetus, the income and the time to do it.”

A few weeks ago, I went on a hike with some friends in the mountains in Colorado. The weather was perfect, the lakes and trees were gorgeous and we even saw a moose.

As I took in the views and breathed the fresh air, I also appreciated what has made hiking possible: industrialization. Hiking is often seen as a natural activity, but there’s nothing natural about it, and almost nobody did it before the industrial revolution.

Continue reading →

Posted in Culture, Human Nature, Music, Politics | Comments Off on Hiking is a Modern Invention