A Cosmic Perspective, and MAGA Kibble

I have a bunch of Trump/MAGA kibble today, but I’ll start with two quotes from the enlightened fringe of humanity.

Carl Sagan, from his book with Ann Druyan, SHADOWS OF FORGOTTEN ANCESTORS. (Which I reviewed here.)

“We humans are like a newborn baby left on a doorstep, with no note explaining who it is, where it came from, what hereditary cargo of attributes and disabilities it might be carrying, or who its antecedents might be. We long to see the orphan’s file. Repeatedly, in many cultures, we invented reassuring fantasies about our parents—about how much they loved us, about how heroic and larger than life they were. As orphans do, we sometimes blamed ourselves for having been abandoned. It must have been our fault. We were too sinful, perhaps, or morally incorrigible. Insecure, we clung to these stories, imposing the strictest penalties on any who dared to doubt them. It was better than nothing, better than admitting our ignorance of our own origins, better than acknowledging that we had been left naked and helpless, a foundling on a doorstep.
As the infant is said to feel it is the center of its Universe, so we were once sure, not just of our central position, but that the Universe was made for us. This old, comfortable conceit, this safe view of the world has been crumbling for five centuries. The more we understood of how the world is put together, the less we needed to invoke a God or gods, and the more remote in time and causality any divine intervention had to be. The cost of coming of age is giving up the security blanket. Adolescence is a roller coaster ride.”

Also quoted recently on Facebook:

…And of course now I can’t find it. I think it was by Lawrence Krauss, a comment about how God appeared only briefly to one violent tribe on one insignificant planet in the entire vast universe, and then disappeared. The comment contained a perspective that most people don’t appreciate.

\\\

Moving on.

In case you’re still wondering how far gone into lunacy MAGA and Trump are, consider this.

NY Times, front page today: Do D.E.I. Bike Paths Exist? The Trump Administration Says Yes., subtitled “The administration has revoked funding for bike paths, and encouraged removing some. A cycling advocate said it is playing on the idea of ‘that dork on a bike.'”

Apparently bicycles are woke, or frou-frou, or unmasculine.

Four years ago, after Joe Biden fell from a bike, Donald Trump made a pledge to the American people.

“I will never, ever ride a bicycle,” he declared.

The joke landed because Mr. Trump is known to be more of a limo-and-golf-cart sort of guy. But more recently, his administration has begun acting on its deep aversion to cycling, revoking federal grants for what it calls “D.E.I. bike lanes.”

In a high-profile move earlier this year, the administration even tried to remove a bike lane near the White House.

Sean Duffy, Mr. Trump’s transportation secretary, has argued that when bike lanes cut into space for cars and trucks, the result is more congestion, “longer travel times and wasted fuel.”

No. More people on bikes means fewer cars. It’s not that hard to figure out. Compare Europe. Oh, but MAGA and Trump would never do that.

\\\

Pure motivated reasoning, by people who disdain the poor while pretending to be Christians.

JMG, today: Capitol Hill Christian Org Releases “Study” Declaring That It’s Unbiblical For Government To Help The Poor

\

No, he didn’t. These people don’t just have a loose grasp upon reality, they are totally bonkers. Living in a fantasy world.

Friendly Atheist, Hemant Mehta, today: Christian Nationalist preacher claims his ministry has raised “over 50 people” from the dead, subtitled “Andrew Wommack has never offered evidence for his extraordinary ‘miracles’—but he expects followers to believe every word”

\

No, this is what being a clueless, arrogant bully looks like.

Right Wing Watch, Kyle Mantyla, yesterday: ‘This Is What Authority Looks Like’: Brigitte Gabriel Gushes Over Trump Renaming Lake Ontario

(Not to mention how many centuries of history Trump thinks he can erase on a whim, and how much infrastructure costs would be to change any amount of documentation and books and atlases and signage to the new name…)

\

Robert Reich, yesterday: Who’s Nuts?

Subtitled: Trump’s “artificially fabricated insanity” is worsening, but Americans are on to him.

Worth quoting.

Friends,

I still come across people who believe Trump won the 2020 election, that the attack on the U.S Capitol on January 6, 2021, was an act of patriotism, that Trump’s subsequent indictments and felonies were Biden’s work, that most immigrants are criminals, that Democrats are evil, that Jews are trying to replace white Christians born in America, that Muslims can’t be trusted, that a significant amount of voting is fraudulent, that we’re winning the war against Iran, that the economy has never been as good, that climate change is a hoax, that Canada poses a threat to the United States and it’s only fair for Lake Ontario to be renamed Lake America.

To label these people “deluded” is to overlook an entire world created by Trump and his assistants, Cabinet secretaries, “spokespeople,” other political appointees, Republican enablers in Congress and state legislatures, and billionaire accomplices in the media (Musk, Murdoch, Pichai, Bezos, Zuckerberg, the Ellisons) — all of whom have reinforced Trump’s “artificially fabricated insanity,” as the philosopher Hannah Arendt once termed the technique of totalitarian tyrants.

Google, for example, just updated its Maps application to rename Lake Ontario “Lake America.” ** (It’s already relabeled the Gulf of Mexico the “Gulf of America.”)

Totalitarian movements, Arendt wrote, succeed not by convincing people of a specific lie but by creating a consistent, logical fictional world that defies ordinary common sense and human experience.

Which raises the questions that a growing number of Americans are asking: Is Trump insane? Are those who believe Trump’s artificially fabricated world insane? Are they making the rest of us insane?

I don’t think the MAGA folks realize how flabbergasted the rest of us are that they are so deluded. Again, see The Good Liars for a steady stream of MAGA on-the-street interviews, in which they spout nonsense and ignorance. Is this another example of the cognitive limitations of the human species?

\\

More shutting down research. If there’s no evidence, they can pretend that problems like this don’t exist.

Politico, 30 Aug 2026: USDA cyclospora research projects shelved amid funding cuts and relocations, subtitled “The shuttering of three projects is expected to hinder vital research at a time when consumers are increasingly worried about the safety of the food supply.”

\\

As are MAGA.

NY Times, Jamelle Bouie, 29 Aug 2026: Trump Is in Open Revolt Against the Constitution [all NYT links are now gift links]

I’ll quote some.

So far, the president’s plot to subvert the integrity of the midterm elections looks like this.

Issue a rule requiring states to give lists of mail-in voters to the Postal Service if their citizens hope to receive mail-in ballots. Knowing that this is a blatantly unconstitutional seizure of the states’ prerogative to run their own elections, count on a federal court to block the rule. Then challenge the injunction, arguing — under the Supreme Court’s “Purcell principle” — that it is too late to make any adjustments to voting procedures, and that the new rules should be treated as the status quo. Then hope that the Supreme Court accepts the argument that the new rules are the status quo and therefore can’t be blocked.

This is rather technical; I’m sure Trump hasn’t figured this out for himself. He has advisors, with their own agendas, like the Project 2025 folks. Again, MAGA conservatives are tribal at base; thus they don’t care about the Constitution, or even about what Jesus said about caring for the poor.

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Cosmology, Human Nature, Lunacy | Leave a comment

More About Science Fiction in Modern Society

First, posted on Facebook about our Napa Valley Wine Train trip yesterday.

Then, more about the role of science fiction in modern society.

The Atlantic, Gal Beckerman, 31 Aug 2026: We Are Living in the Fantasy World of 13-Year-Old Boys, subtitled: “Many of the tech billionaires who built our world have taken the wrong lessons from their favorite science fiction.”

This is more about the new Jill Lepore book.

After reading Jill Lepore’s The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State, I have a new destination for a time machine, should I ever finally get my hands on one. I’d set the dial to some night in the late 1970s or ’80s and visit the boyhood rooms of the Silicon Valley titans Elon Musk, Peter Thiel, and Sam Altman. Then I’d confiscate all of their science fiction. Isaac Asimov, Arthur C. Clarke, Robert Heinlein—all of it.

No. This cannot be the response.

Lepore discusses Asimov, and Douglas Adams, and Star Trek. Asimov addressed ethics in his “three laws of robotics.” And then longtermism. And finally, about Heinlein.

As I was writing this, Bill Gates, who gushes all the time about his childhood love of science fiction, published a nearly 6,000-word essay worrying about AI. (He expanded on his thoughts in a Radio Atlantic interview.) He describes himself now as an “innovation lover” who “is scared and says we’re not ready and we’re crossing thresholds.” Heinlein was his favorite sci-fi writer—Gates particularly loved the 1961 novel Stranger in a Strange Land as a teenager. It is the story of a human who grows up on Mars and comes back to Earth; this traveler’s perspective reveals how contingent our established norms are, how changeable. Gates loved the “cool technology” in it, and the idea of “grokking,” a Martian term for connecting with a person or concept so deeply that you feel a part of it (Musk of course borrowed the name for his AI chatbot). But the Microsoft co-founder now points out that Heinlein was also illustrating the perils of believing that anything is inevitable—even our technology. This, he says, is the “grown-up” lesson.

Beware teenage obsessions. Many people see science fiction as some kind of adolescent fantasy of power — though I would say that this is more typical of fantasy, in which a single hero saves the world. Yet science fiction can be interpreted naively.

I would tentatively place this into the bucket about complex ideas reduced to simplex thinking.

\\\

The essence of the conservative mindset. Resistance to change.

JMG, today: Duffy Celebrates End To Stop/Start Buttons On Cars

He resists anything that is different from the way things were when he grew up. Does he miss clutches too?

Posted in science fiction | Leave a comment

Christian Nationalism, and the Dissipation of Science Fiction Into Popular Culture

  • The arrogance of Christian Nationalism;
  • How some of science fiction has become absorbed into even literary culture.
– – –

From a few days ago.

NY Times, David French, 20 Aug 2026: JD Vance Has a Mind-Bending Vision for America

JD Vance doesn’t think our nation is Christian enough to be truly free. Your faithlessness has broken the social compact, and now it is time for the government to seize greater control.

Continue reading

Posted in Religion, science fiction | Comments Off on Christian Nationalism, and the Dissipation of Science Fiction Into Popular Culture

Truth, Myths, and Levels of Reality

  • Given inevitable pandemics and inevitable conspiracy mongering, could AI be the answer?;
  • A new Sean Tan book, and how perhaps some truths can only be told through myth;
  • Bruce Ledewitz at OnlySky recalls a time when the US government was lawful;
  • Mahler 7, Claudio Abbado.
– – –

How to deal with the next pandemic given the inevitable conspiracy theories that undermine constructive responses?

Slate, Molly Oldmstead, 26 Aug 26: Public Health Advocates Are So Desperate for Help Against Conspiracies They’ve Turned to the Place You’d Least Expect

How about… A.I.?

Continue reading

Posted in Human Nature, Music, Personal history, Technology | Comments Off on Truth, Myths, and Levels of Reality

Is Science Fiction Becoming Obsolete?

  • Jill Lepore on how Silicon Valley misreads classic science fiction;
  • Kibble: Trumps wants to rename everything; Reich calls Trump petty and incompetent; how the Supreme Court is less and less interested in facts; and about ICE’s new electronic glove torture devices that leave no mark;
  • Mahler 6, Michael Tilson Thomas.
– – –

I have a nascent theme about why science fiction may be obsolete, and/or why it’s increasingly less popular than fantasy. Maybe all the good ideas are used up; maybe all the good ideas are turning out to be increasingly less plausible; or perhaps it’s that fantasy appeals to basic human nature and its indefatigable beliefs in ghosts and demons and magic and gods. On the second point is what I called five months ago The Most Dangerous Vision, the idea that perhaps all of science fiction’s best ideas are turning out to be obsolete or implausible. Time travel, faster-than-light travel. And now I would say this would be because our speculations about the future and about the universe have been hemmed in by our intuitive thinking that is scale-blind and realm-blind. Without realizing it we ‘flatten’ the universe by thinking everything new and strange must conform to the protocols of human existence. If a person has a father, so must the universe, and so on.

Let’s look at this. (In addition, Lepore was also on KQED’s Forum two days ago, audio and transcript here, concerning her new book The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State.)

Scientific American, Brianne Kane, yesterday: Silicon Valley reads a lot of science fiction. It often gets it wrong, subtitled “Historian Jill Lepore explains what tech leaders miss in their favorite stories—and why the fight over AI data centers may be where the machine stops” Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Lunacy, Music, science fiction | Comments Off on Is Science Fiction Becoming Obsolete?

Self-Destruction and Magical Thinking

  • Self-destruction: Of the US military, of the Kennedy Center;
  • How MAGA’s religious freedom doesn’t apply to Muslims;
  • Dimwits: Darline Graham, advocates for “conservative-based” science; a GOP nominee who thinks humans and dinosaurs lived at the same time;
  • Liars, vanity projects (Trump already has a secret bunker), woke paintings;
  • Mahler’s 6th, by Michael Tilson Thomas.
– – –

Today in American self-destruction. There seem to be a couple such items every day.

NY Times, yesterday: Hegseth’s Purge of Top Generals Leaves the Army Rudderless, subtitled “The leadership vacuum comes as the Army is trying to adapt to a new kind of war dominated by deadly drones.”

I don’t quite see how learning to deal with drones is related to firing a bunch of senior military officials.

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, conservatives, Human Nature, Music, Politics, Psychology, Religion | Comments Off on Self-Destruction and Magical Thinking

Cognitive Overload?

  • Is humanity suffering information overload?
  • Why people hate data centers;
  • Why people hate the government;
  • Is this all about the increasing complexity of the world, and the limits of human cognition?
  • Comments about Trump and Canada from Robert Charles Wilson and Jim Wright;
  • And evidence from The Good Liars about those who believe Trump is God.
– – –

Another running theme here, alongside the aspects of reality that lie outside human intuition and human understanding, is that the increasing complexity of the modern world has gone past similar limitations of intuition and understanding. For some.

OnlySky, Susan Fourtané, yesterday: The cost of information overload, subtitled “Our brains’ ability to process information hasn’t kept pace with the tools that deliver it.”

Every day, we consume more information than any previous generation in history. News alerts arrive by the minute. Social media feeds refresh endlessly. Emails pile up; if we dare to not check email for one day, we fear the results could be catastrophic. Podcasts compete for our attention during our commute. An AI assistant can fill up our agenda with meetings and tasks which become overwhelming in their own right; we feel bad if we want to cancel them to take the afternoon off because we feel mentally exhausted.

Continue reading

Posted in conservatives, Decline, Education, Evolution, Human Nature | Comments Off on Cognitive Overload?

Penn Jillette, GOD, NO!

Subtitled “Signs You May Already Be an Atheist and Other Magical Tales”
(Simon & Schuster, August 2011, 231pp)

This is an odd book that is superficially about religion and atheism and the author’s own version of a “ten commandments,” but is more about the author himself, entertainingly so, than a serious theological treatise.

Jillette (that’ 2 Ls, 2 Ts) is the talking half of the magician duo Penn & Teller, whose current show, Fool Us, we catch on Friday evenings if our dinner schedule permits. And we saw them once, at the Rio Hotel in Las Vegas, where their show is filmed, 20 some years ago. I like them, or at least Penn, the one who talks, because he doesn’t take himself serious, he’s funny, and he wants you to understand that magic is just tricks. He contrasts himself with some other magicians who want to spook you into believing that something supernatural is going on. At their Rio show, the pair ends by performing an elaborate magic trick and then showing you exactly how they did it. Which is as much fun to see as the actual trick.

Jillette is also known, via a couple books, as being an unabashed atheist, in a self-deprecating way. All in good fun. This book is his answer to an invitation to create an atheist Ten Commandments. He does so, with a lot of stories and rambling along the way.

Continue reading

Posted in Book Notes, Humor, Religion | Comments Off on Penn Jillette, GOD, NO!

The Proper Study

  • The proper study of mankind, if not in the way Alexander Pope meant;
  • Powers of Ten, and the range of human intuition and understanding;
  • If Pluto is a planet, so are dozens of other spherical bodies.
  • A passionate performance of Mahler’s 5th.
– – –

I’m steadily tweaking and updating my Outline of Themes. It needs much work. Three items today. This illustrates the second:

The first: the primary issue goes back to that famous Essay on Man by Alexander Pope, which famously begins:

Know then thyself, presume not God to scan;
The proper study of Mankind is Man.

Continue reading

Posted in Astronomy, Human Nature, Music, Philosophy, Science | Comments Off on The Proper Study

Kevin, Sean, Darline

  • Noting Kevin Kelly’s substack;
  • David French, Sean Duffy, Harvard, and fear of corruption;
  • World hunger is declining;
  • How is Sharia Law worse than Christian Nationalism? (asking for a friend);
  • Ignoramous Darline Graham pivots to a safe conservative target: trans kids.
– – –

Nothing vital today. Let’s note this.

Boing Boing, Mark Frauenfelder, 18 Aug 2026: Kevin Kelly: AI will be a microscope we point at our own minds

I noted the anniversary of his book Out of Control a couple months ago, but didn’t highlight the fact that he has a substack, KK. Add it to my rotation? For a while. It already takes me an hour a day to visit my usual sites. His latest post is Without a Theory of Intelligence.

Continue reading

Posted in conservatives, Education, Religion, Science | Comments Off on Kevin, Sean, Darline