Mirror Realities

Can’t resist another round of political links this afternoon, about the Alice in Wonderland, mirror-universe that conservatives and Trump-supporters apparently live in. In which they, and those of us living in the real objective world, believe the other is the purveyor of crime and evil. While, to anyone with half a wit of sense, …. well, you can finish. It’s obvious. Let’s start with this objective reporting of an event.

NY Times, 28 Mar 2024: Trump, Attending Wake of Slain N.Y.P.D. Officer, Pushes Campaign Message on Crime, subtitled “Mr. Trump called the officer’s death a horrible tragedy and, as he often does on the trail, broadly called for a crackdown on violent crime without mentioning specific policies.”

As hundreds of police officers and family members stood outside a Long Island funeral home, former President Donald J. Trump attended on Thursday the wake of a New York City police officer who was killed in the line of duty days earlier.

Then, Mr. Trump, who is facing four criminal cases, including one in Manhattan that is going to trial in less than three weeks, stood in front of more than a dozen police officers and proclaimed the need for the country to “get back to law and order.”

The obvious reaction of many: let’s start with you, Donald.

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Lunacy, Politics | Comments Off on Mirror Realities

A History of Progress and Backlash

  • Two items about Fareed Zakaria and his new book;
  • Robert Reich on Roger Ailes;
  • How “DEI” is now substituting for the N-word.

*

There’s a new book out this week by Fareed Zakaria, whose 2020 book, Ten Lessons for a Post-Pandemic World, I quite admired. (Review here.)

So I bought the new one too, which is about “progress and backlash from 1600 to the present,” a theme which fascinates me. Why are so many people so eager to abandon the progress made since the Enlightenment, both in politics (democracy) and science (the anti-vaxxers and flat earthers and…)

NY Times, David Brooks, 28 Mar 2024: The Great Struggle for Liberalism

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, progress | Comments Off on A History of Progress and Backlash

Case Study of the Psychology of Conspiracy Theorists?

  • First, a quote about progressives and conservatives, the future and the past;
  • Then more about the conspiracy thinking about the Baltimore bridge collapse, with examples from PolitiFact, CNN, and CFI (Center for Inquiry);
  • And how the construction workers who fell from the bridge were immigrants, whom many Americans demonize, yet like the ones who have built America.

*

Saw this quote on Facebook, and verified it (never trust any quote on Facebook) to the extent of finding it on one of those websites that collects quotes.

For progressive people the present is the beginning of the future. For conservative people the present is the end of the past.

Karl Mannheim

This is consistent with the MAGA crowd yearning to return to a (mythical) lost golden age, on the one hand, and on the other, that saying “Work as if you live in the early days of a better nation” — long an epigraph on Patrick Nielsen Hayden’s Making Light blog — which it turns out (Google!) was said by Alasdair Gray, Scottish author of, among other things, Poor Things, basis for the recent film. Coincidence!

Continue reading

Posted in conservatives, progress | Comments Off on Case Study of the Psychology of Conspiracy Theorists?

Perspectives from Reality and Fantasy

  • How the first scene in Netflix’s “3 Body Problem” is seen differently by conservatives and progressives;
  • Daniel Kahneman, RIP, who realized that people are not rational;
  • More right-wing conspiracy theories about the Baltimore bridge collapse;
  • And items about an earthquake, crime and drugs, and banning abortion pills.

CNN, Harmeet Kaur, 27 Mar 2024: Conservatives and liberals alike can’t stop talking about this scene in ‘3 Body Problem’

I’ve only watched the first episode of “3 Body Problem” (as Netflix stylizes the adaptation of Cixin Liu’s The Three-Body Problem — a novel I reviewed here back in 2015), but it’s been enough for me to recognize the scene at issue in this article.

That first episode

Continue reading

Posted in conservatives, progress | Comments Off on Perspectives from Reality and Fantasy

Necessary Stories, and Most of the Others

  • About this morning’s Baltimore bridge collapse, and the right-wing conspiracy-theory accusations about it;
  • Paul Krugman on how Republicans want to bring down Obamacare to support their notion that the government can never do good things;
  • And a Doonesbury cartoon about the need to believe.

Very early this morning a container ship struck a bridge in Baltimore and knocked it down. It’s been all over the news, all day. (Here’s a current CNN summary.) And I can’t resist noting a few reactions from the right-wing/MAGA/Republican loonies, who blame anything and everything on whatever they don’t like, especially Biden and Democrats.

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Economics, Lunacy, Narrative | Comments Off on Necessary Stories, and Most of the Others

Oliver Sacks, THE MAN WHO MISTOOK HIS WIFE FOR A HAT

Like the Pinker and Wilson volumes I’ve covered here recently, this is another classic nonfiction book, one I first read years ago without taking notes (maybe before I began taking notes on my reading). So I skimmed through it again last week to capture essential points. This won’t be a detailed summary/review, like I did for those other two.

Subtitled: “and Other Clinical Tales.” (First published 1985 by Summit Books. Edition shown is trade paperback reprint, Perennial Library, 1987. x + 243pp, including 10pp chapter-by-chapter bibliographic notes.)

Sacks, who died in 2015, was a clinical neurologist who specialized in neurological disorders. He was famous for this book, with its intriguing title, and for previous book Awakenings, which was made into a movie in 1990 starring Robin Williams and Robert DeNiro. He wrote numerous other books too, including one about music. (Also, he was a burly guy with a huge beard, a bodybuilder, and gay, though he was celibate for 40 years.)

Continue reading

Posted in Book Notes, MInd, Psychology, science fiction | Comments Off on Oliver Sacks, THE MAN WHO MISTOOK HIS WIFE FOR A HAT

How Humans Live by Stories, and Myths

  • A NYT essay that wonders if, given how political persuasions are aligned with community, we actually ever think for ourselves;
  • An example from the fringe about a Republican who wants to outlaw “chemtrails”;
  • A review of a book about the idea of finding a new mythology for the United States;
  • And mention of a forthcoming book by Fareed Zakaria about progress and backlash.

*

The point here is valid, sorta, but I think he over-simplifies.

NY Times, guest essay by Neil Gross, 24 Mar 2024: When It Comes to Politics, Are Any of Us Really Thinking for Ourselves?

Continue reading

Posted in Culture, History, Narrative, Psychology | Comments Off on How Humans Live by Stories, and Myths

An Anthropologist from Mars Considers the Evidence

  • What would a hypothetical anthropologist from another planet conclude about humanity from these several items today?
  • Charlie Kirk insists Christians must vote Republican; a former ESPN anchor thinks Satan knocked out her teeth; Charlie Kirk thinks Haiti is infested with demonic voodoo that turns people into cats;
  • Amanda Marcotte on how evangelicals like raunch, for themselves, but not sex, for others;
  • PolitiFact supports the claim that 96% of job growth since 1989 has been under Democratic presidents;
  • Paul Krugman on politics in Ohio: how Trump’s trade war didn’t benefit them, while Biden’s policies have.
  • And considering how the visiting anthropologist would rate human intelligence.

What conclusions would be drawn from the following news items?

Hemant Mehta, Friendly Atheist, 22 Mar 2024: Charlie Kirk echoes thoughtless claim that you can’t “be a Christian and vote Democrat”, subtitled “Who needs theology when you have Trump?”

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, conservatives, Economics, Lunacy | Comments Off on An Anthropologist from Mars Considers the Evidence

Putting Things Into Perspective: Science, Expertise, Liberalism

Items today are follow-ups to items from the past couple days, it turns out.

  • Ethan Siegel at Big Think puts that dark matter claim into the perspective of how science works;
  • Tom Nichols’ update of The Death of Expertise aligns with yesterday’s piece about America’s decline;
  • A new book by Fareed Zakaria attempts to explain the backlash to the liberal revolution of the past three decades.

First of all, a very thorough response to that study that claimed to disprove the idea of dark matter, which I last wrote about here.

Big Think, Ethan Siegel, 22 Mar 2024: Ask Ethan: Has a new study disproven dark matter and dark energy?, subtitled “There are a wide variety of theoretical studies that call our standard model of cosmology into question. Here’s what they really mean.”

Continue reading

Posted in Astronomy, Science, science fiction | Comments Off on Putting Things Into Perspective: Science, Expertise, Liberalism

Exceptionalism, and Science Fiction

  • A screed by Brian Karem at Salon about how “America has lost its collective mind”;
  • How ideas of American exceptionalism have been reflected in 20th century science fiction;
  • Examples about “don’t say gay” laws; Trump’s fascist rhetoric; Trump’s dementia; how Trump fans will take his “bloodbath” comment literally; a North Carolina politician who calls for the public executions of Biden and Obama; and Charlie Kirk promising to fight if the election doesn’t go his way.

No doubt America is exceptional, in the size of its defense budget at least. (And, actually, in the number of its Nobel-Prize winning scientists, too.) But the word ‘exceptional’ has other connotations…

*

About this piece, I wonder, in what sense are all Americans to blame? But it does suggest how this applies to science fiction.

Salon, Brian Karem, 21 Mar 2024: We have met the enemy and he is us, subtitled “And with no sense of humor, the joke is on us”

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, conservatives, Politics, science fiction | Comments Off on Exceptionalism, and Science Fiction