Subtitled: “The Psychology of Souls, Destiny, and the Meaning of Life”

(Norton, hardcover, 2011, 252pp, including 47pp notes, additional reading, and index.)
(UK title The God Instinct: The Psychology of Souls, Destiny and the Meaning of Life, also 2011)
I have a short shelf of eight or ten books that I’ve read over the past decade or more that I’ve never gotten around to writing up here, mostly because they’re very substantial books and I took *lots* of notes on them, so the chores of boiling them down to blog posts has been daunting. But these are some of the books that have most influenced my thinking, and so I’m making a new resolution to get these posted by the end of the year. Aside from the present book, they include two by Pinker, and others by Dawkins, Hitchens, Coyne, and Harris. (Then there are even older ones that I took notes on back in the ‘90s and 2000s, long before I began posting such notes on this blog. I’ll see what I can salvage from them too.)
This book by Bering I bought when it came out in early 2011. I think the author was unknown to me, and I may or may not have read reviews of the book. It followed books in the 2000s by the “new atheists,” including Harris, Dawkins, Hitchens, and Dennett, that pointed out various things non-believers had noticed about religion that the religious apparently had not considered. Critics found the strident, and found reasons to dismiss them. (After all, they had *grown up* with their religions.) Bering, coming along a few years later, provided a new perspective, answering *why* people are subject to beliefs in souls and supernatural beings. Short answer: human nature, just as we had read about in Wilson’s ON HUMAN NATURE and later in Pinker’s HOW THE MIND WORKS and THE BLANK SLATE. And not just human nature, but human nature as evolved by natural selection to promote survival. That is, there’s survival value to believing things that are not true. Cool, huh?
Anyway, my approach to this book and the others will be to read through my notes and clean up their readability, without necessarily trying to condense them, and post them. But along the way I’ll extract some key points, and list those first, as a summary ahead of the full notes.
Continue reading →