The Law vs. Tribal Priorities

What strikes me about the law, i.e. the judicial system, is how easily laws and principles and even past supreme court decisions, which presumably are established precedents, can be bent or even overturned toward the ideological preferences of the politicians and the justices and judges currently in power. (The law, while presuming to cite established precedents as if they were established scientific conclusions, is actually nothing like science or mathematics.)

More going back in time, and undoing progress made in previous generations.

Slate, Richard L. Hasen, yesterday: The Supreme Court’s Conservatives Just Issued the Worst Ruling in a Century, subtitled “This evisceration of the Voting Rights Act requires us to take SCOTUS reform more seriously.”

Because the decision is transparently in support of the current administration’s naked support for white supremacy. This is why the decision is so cleanly split between the ‘conservative’ justices and the ‘liberal’ ones.

Wednesday’s 6–3 party-line decision in Louisiana v. Callais will go down in history as one of the most pernicious and damaging Supreme Court decisions of the past century. All six Republican-appointed justices on the court signed onto Justice Samuel Alito’s opinion gutting what remained of the Voting Rights Act protections for minority voters, while pretending they were merely making technical tweaks to the act.

Also:

\\\

About King Charles’ visit.

The Atlantic, Jonathan Chait, yesterday: Donald Trump’s Disturbing Welcome for King Charles, subtitled “At the White House, the president embraced the idea that the nation is an Anglo-Saxon one.”

President Trump welcomed the British monarch King Charles III to the White House yesterday and gave a speech that, on its surface, expressed warmth between the two countries. But its true purpose was darker. Trump’s speech stamped his imprimatur on an ascendant view of American history and politics—one that is controversial even on the American right, and that walks up to the edge of white nationalism.

The analysis Trump endorsed is that America is defined not by its founding values but by its Anglo-Saxon cultural and genetic heritage. This idea has radical consequences, some of which have already manifested under the administration.

Trump’s sentiment was unmistakable. “Long before Americans had a nation or a constitution, we first had a culture, a character, and a creed,” he said, proceeding to depict the Founders not as rebels against the English crown but instead its loyal heirs: “Their veins ran with Anglo-Saxon courage. Their hearts beat with an English faith in standing firm for what is right, good, and true.”

And so on.

That line, asserting that America is not merely an idea, has become a cliché among a faction on the right known as the national conservatives. When the natcons say this, as they do all the time, they are not merely making the obvious point that the United States is composed of a landmass and a population. They are advancing a series of associated ideas. They believe that America is the product of white, European settlers (a conviction they share, ironically, with left-wing critics); that Americanness is a genetic inheritance and therefore an identity immigrants cannot obtain (an idea conveyed by Trump’s reference to Anglo-Saxon veins); and that, most controversially, the values articulated by the founding documents are less important than the natural rights of what the natcons call “heritage Americans” to rule the land in perpetuity.

Until recently, most Republicans would have considered this account of American history bizarre. …

Reagan said America is an idea. So did Bush. Since then Republicans are simply becoming more tribalistic and racist. All of this aligns with my notion that conservatives these days aren’t concerned with the principles of the Constitution (or what Jesus said) but with base, tribal thinking. Blood and soil, not shared values. But I don’t have a take about why is this happening. The increasing complexity of the world, perhaps?

\

Making the same point:

Heather Cox Richardson, April 29, 2026

King Charles and Queen Camilla are in the U.S. on a state visit, and in his speech welcoming them to the White House yesterday, Trump redefined the United States from a nation based on the principles of the Enlightenment, as it has historically been understood, to one based in the white nationalist ideas of blood and soil.

“Long before Americans had a nation or a constitution, we first had a culture, a character, and a creed,” Trump said. “For nearly two centuries before the Revolution, this land was settled and forged by men and women who bore in their souls the blood and noble spirit of the British. Here on a wild and untamed continent, they set loose the ancient English love of liberty and…Great Britain’s distinctive sense of glory, destiny, and pride.”

Yet again, this is about American conservatives regressing to primitive tribal values, and renouncing the ideals set forth in the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution.

King Charles spoke, invoking some of those ideas. Cox ends:

King Charles urged the U.S. to “ignore the clarion calls to become ever more inward-looking,” and reminded his listeners that “America’s words carry weight and meaning, as they have since Independence. The actions of this great Nation matter even more.” He called for the U.S. and the U.K. to “rededicate ourselves to each other in the selfless service of our peoples and of all the peoples of the world.”

Appearing to miss the point completely, at about the time King Charles finished his speech, the official social media account of the White House posted a picture of Trump and King Charles with the caption “TWO KINGS.”

Trump is an ignorant, dangerous, moron.

\\\

Brief items.

  • Slate, Shrin Ali, today: There’s Something More Sinister Beneath Trump’s Ballroom Obsession
  • Subtitled: It’s another manifestation of his theory of the presidency.
  • “Trump has shown he has no interest in seeking real approval from Congress for anything on his agenda, adopting the “unitary executive” theory, which holds that presidents singularly control everything within the executive branch. It’s why Trump never bothered to get congressional approval before starting a war with Iran, capturing Venezuelan dictator Nicolás Maduro, or gutting federal agencies like the Education Department, U.S. Agency for International Development, and others. And he admitted as much, wrongly proclaiming on Truth Social that congressional approval had never been given over construction projects at the White House.”
  • In other words, he’s acting like a dictator.
  • Religious lunacy. Dangerous religious lunacy. I saw a cartoon on Facebook, a white couple sitting in a boiling cauldron in a jungle while two black natives said, Stop interfering with our religious expression! This is comparable.
  • Right Wing Watch, Kyle Mantyla, yesterday: Micah Beckwith Says The Death Penalty Is ‘A Blessing’
  • He says this because… the condemned “is being given the opportunity ‘to be in the presence of Jesus’ after they are executed.”

\

  • John Pavlovitz, 28 Apr 2026: Patriotic Americans, Actual Christians, and Decent Humans Stand With Jimmy Kimmel. Let me just quote a portion.

    Watching the Right assembling online with virtual torches and pitchforks, engaging in wild histrionics and performative pearl-clutching, while calling for the head of television host Jimmy Kimmel, one has to marvel at his rank-and-file’s steadfast ability to defy reality.

    It’s staggering when you compare the man they’re crusading against and the one they’re emotionally tethered to…

    Jimmy Kimmel isn’t responsible for the deaths of countless people.

    Donald Trump is.

    Jimmy Kimmel isn’t a court-adjudicated rapist.

    Donald Trump is.

    Jimmy Kimmel isn’t a 34-count felon.

    Donald Trump is.

    Jimmy Kimmel didn’t incite a violent insurrection at our nation’s Capitol in an effort to overturn a free and fair election, harm members of Congress, and prevent a peaceful transfer of power.

    Donald Trump did.

    Jimmy Kimmel’s name isn’t listed tens of thousands of times in the Epstein Files.

    Donald Trump’s is.

    Jimmy Kimmel doesn’t have dozens of credible sexual assault accusations.

    Donald Trump does.

    Jimmy Kimmel didn’t threaten an entire civilization with destruction.

    Donald Trump did.

    Jimmy Kimmel didn’t bomb a girl’s school in Iran.

    Donald Trump has.

    That’s half of it. You get the idea.

    \\

    Again, this isn’t news, not a surprise, just another observation.

    The Bulwark, Jonathan V. Last, today: MAGA Has a Eugenics Gene, subtitled “Trump’s movement is repulsed by people who are different.”

    Yes, this is elementary tribalism, which humanity will have to overcome if it is to have a longer-term future (one that depends on coordinated effort by the entire human race to avoid existential risks).

    One of the under-appreciated aspects of Trumpism is its aversion to—what euphemism shall we employ?—dysgenic types.

    Trump famously mocked a disabled reporter in front of thousands of people and has a well-documented distaste for disabled or disfigured soldiers.

    There is the MAGA movement’s constant murmuring about racial purity—advocating for “heritage Americans,” warning about “vermin” infesting the country, voicing concerns about groups of people who are “poisoning the blood” of the nation with their “bad genes.”

    There is the obsession with erasing public acknowledgment that trans people exist.

    There is the disgust at neurodivergence and the view of autism as an “epidemic” to be stamped out.

    And while everyone is paying attention to the big-ticket stuff—the Iran war, the looming bond-market crisis, the Putinesque levels of corruption—the administration has been quietly doing some soft eugenics.

    Let me tell you about “the most pro-life president” in American history . . .

    With history.

This entry was posted in Conservative Resistance, conservatives, Lunacy, Politics, Tribalism. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *