Intercessory Prayer and Science

About a month ago I put together a post in part about how belief in prayer reflects a fundamental inability to understand cause and effect in the real, actual, physical world; that post is here.

I had a current link at hand, what prompted the topic, but I couldn’t find an older link about a more recent and thorough study about so-called “intercessory prayer.” Now I’ve found that link; it’s an article that apparently cycles on and off the homepage of Free Inquiry (https://secularhumanism.org/) as a feature article, and earlier today it cycled back on.

This is worth reviewing closely because it’s an excellent example about how to actually test a religious claim, and about how the faithful will find ways to dismiss the evidence when it conflicts with their beliefs. Again, somehow the evidence of cause and effect (or non effect) that they would apply to other situations doesn’t apply when it comes to their own “sincerely held religious beliefs.” Apparently sincerity trumps evidence and rationality.

Continue reading

Posted in Religion, Science | Comments Off on Intercessory Prayer and Science

Kids These Days, Bauerlein and Will Style

Beware cranky old men complaining about kids these days. Surely George F. Will, a renowned (conservative) political commentator, knows better.

Washington Post, George F. Will, 8 July 2022: How millennials became aggressively illiberal, censorious young adults

Continue reading

Posted in Culture, Technology | Comments Off on Kids These Days, Bauerlein and Will Style

Ensoulment and Miscarriages

Here’s a nice essay that observes how the prevelance of spontaneous abortions — miscarriages — doesn’t seem consistent with the theological position of “ensoulment,” the notion that God inserts the just-feritilized embryo with a soul.

Continue reading

Posted in Evolution, Religion | Comments Off on Ensoulment and Miscarriages

Fiddler on the Roof

Over the past couple evenings we’ve watched the movie version of a musical I had never seen before, in any form: Fiddler on the Roof. I was aware it was a big-hit musical, back in the 1960s or ’70s, in roughly the same era as West Side Story and The Sound of Music. The main thing I knew was that it included a couple three memorable songs, in particular “Sunrise, Sunset,” a moving, even heartbreaking song about parents observing how quickly their children grow up. It’s been on my list of favorite sentimental songs (stub list here) for years. Here’s the wedding scene with the song:


Continue reading

Posted in Movies, Music, Social Progress | Comments Off on Fiddler on the Roof

Failed Policies? Or Disingenuous Ones?

Republican policies have failed the nation — Thom Hartmann explains how. Republican positions have been wrong, wrong, wrong — David Brin explains why. Or have they? The rich are getting richer, and the fundamentalists are getting their way. Perhaps it’s just that Republicans are playing a different game, and are being disingenuous about it. More about this at the end.

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Politics | Comments Off on Failed Policies? Or Disingenuous Ones?

The Gun Nuts, Like the Terrorists, Are Winning

The terrorists of 9/11 won by not destroying the country, but by instilling a paranoia in American society that entails those excruciating TSA lines to board airplanes that involve taking off shoes and belts. By millions of us, every day. That has gradually eroded civil trust in the 20 years since, and arguably has contributed to the political divide in this country. Now the gun nuts — er, second amendment absolutists — are doing the same, by undermining the confidence ordinary Americans have to participate in ordinary, traditional civic events. It’s only going to get worse.

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Culture, Politics | Comments Off on The Gun Nuts, Like the Terrorists, Are Winning

Climate Change Denial and Christian Nationalists

Today, links about the threats, to American democracy and the survival of the planet, from conservatives, especially the religious ones.

NYT, Paul Krugman, 4 July 2022: Another Step Toward Climate Apocalypse

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Religion, Science | Comments Off on Climate Change Denial and Christian Nationalists

Independence

It’s always struck me that America (that is, the US) stands defiantly independent against the rest of the world, secure in its self-righteousness and uncaring or even contemptuous of what other countries think about it. After all, they’re not the US, and the US is the best. Just ask most USians.

My favorite print magazine (as I’ve said) is The Week, a sort of Reader’s Digest of other magazines, consolidating news on a wide variety of topics, and including opinions from a variety of perspectives. Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Culture, Politics | Comments Off on Independence

The Blue Nation and the Red Nation

“The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, and wiser people so full of doubts.” — variations by Bertrand Russell, William Butler Yeats, and others.

Continue reading

Posted in Conservative Resistance, Politics | Comments Off on The Blue Nation and the Red Nation

Michio Kaku: THE GOD EQUATION, 2

I’ve spent my blogging time this afternoon refining yesterday’s post about Michio Kaku’s book THE GOD EQUATION. I’m not sure reducing 20 bullets about each chapter to 10 bullets will make much difference, in terms of my goal to pass along knowledge I’ve gained to anyone reading this blog. But that’s what I did today, and I’m always thinking toward the big picture, that my accumulation of blog essays and summaries of significant books will add up to something, in the long run.

About this book — I remain a bit queasy about the author’s consideration of a “grand planner,” as if one were needed to explain the mathematical consistency of the universe, which he is agnostic about only because it can’t be proved. I am much more inclined to be persuaded — about the “reason” for the existence of our universe — by the idea that only one set of physical constants and mathematical principles is consistent. That somehow, our universe exists because nothing else can exist. And that, if were we far more intelligent, this would be obvious.

At the same time, I suspect these big issues are simply incomprehensible to primates like us, wandering around on the surface of an average planet, forever blinkered by the limitations of our senses, and our capacity to understand abstract concepts. Just think how tiny a proportion of the human population is able to understand the physics so far identified. We are like dogs thinking we might be able to understand arithmetic, and oblivious to concepts like geometry and calculus.

Posted in Book Notes, Cosmology, Physics | Comments Off on Michio Kaku: THE GOD EQUATION, 2